regulation and policy

SEC staff says certain crypto buybacks and staking tokens fall outside securities laws

14Importance
closedStatus
7News media
7Pieces
Published
Updated
Since then
5 new reports

SEC staff published new FAQs on Sept. 25 covering token buybacks, staking receipt tokens, network development and promotion. The guidance said some buybacks on a functional network, some staking receipt tokens, and some wrapped tokens can fall outside securities treatment, while the staff also said the answers are nonbinding and do not change existing law. [13135][13225][13133][14173]

Key claims & sources

✓
SEC staff issued new FAQs covering token buybacks, staking receipt tokens, network development, marketing and secondary-market activity.
✓
The staff said the FAQs are nonbinding and were not approved by the commission.
✓
The staff said announcing buybacks of non-security tokens on a functional crypto system does not amount to a promise of essential managerial efforts under the investment-contract test.
✓
The FAQs said promoting a network’s current uses generally would not create an expectation of profit.
✓
The guidance said some staking receipt tokens, including protocol staking and certain one-for-one wrapped tokens, may fall outside federal securities rules.
✓
SEC staff said the answers on buybacks, staking receipt tokens and network development were issued alongside new guidance on wrapped assets and functional crypto networks.
✓
The new FAQs also said a buyback can become relevant to an investment-contract analysis when an issuer presents it as a way to create yield or returns.

What it means

Users, token issuers and trading desks that follow SEC staff interpretations now have a clearer set of staff views on buybacks, staking receipt tokens and network promotion. That matters tomorrow morning because the FAQs address how those topics fit into securities analysis, including functional networks and wrapped assets.

In practice, the update leaves room for announcing some buybacks and for treating some staking receipt tokens as outside securities treatment, while also leaving the staff’s answers nonbinding. What stays the same is that the FAQs are not a commission-approved rule and do not replace existing law.

Market reaction i

Total crypto marketall crypto assets combined no single asset in the event: read against the whole market
first headline
+0.2% 2 h before
+0.1% 4 h after
$2.9Tmarket cap at publication
12data points

The move was larger before the first headline than after. That is an observation, not an explanation: the market also moves on things nobody publishes.

Coverage timeline

Every piece in order, with the time its news medium declares — if it is not believable we use ours and say so — and what it added to what was already known at that point. Arriving first is not the same as adding something.

first
Sep 25 20:03
+10 min
Sep 25 20:14
The Defiant context
Its angle: managerial, constitute, undertake; with quotes
+29 min
Sep 25 20:32
The Block context
Its angle: expectation, promoting, addresses
+9 h 29 m
Sep 26 05:32
crypto.news echo
No new facts: clarified, alongside, networks
+19 h 26 m
Sep 26 15:30
NewsBTC context
Its angle: automatically, relationship, repurchases; with quotes
+19 h 57 m
Sep 26 16:00
AMBCrypto echo
No new facts: contracts, several, address
+1 d 16 h
Sep 27 13:01
Decrypt echo
No new facts: attorney, shift, works; with quotes

Has this happened before?

WhenWhat happenedFigure
43 days ago SEC’s Peirce Urges Zero-Knowledge Proofs to Reduce KYC Data Collection event 1 actors in common · 4 news media
44 days ago Stocks Go Onchain: What the SEC's Innovation Exemption Means for Solana event 1 actors in common · 2 news media
44 days ago SEC Clears Tokenized Stocks To Trade Onchain As CFTC Widens Software Relief event 1 actors in common · 2 news media