Kalshi Loses Fourth Circuit Bid to Block Maryland Gambling Rules as Judges Split on Why
- Published
- Updated
A federal appeals panel in the Fourth Circuit left Maryland’s sports-wagering rules in place against Kalshi’s sports event contracts, after affirming a lower court’s August 2025 refusal to grant a preliminary injunction. The panel’s Nov. 18 decision also said the Commodity Exchange Act does not clearly override Maryland’s gaming laws for event contracts on a CFTC-regulated designated contract market.
Key claims & sources
What it means
Kalshi is operating at the point where federal derivatives regulation meets state gambling law, and Maryland is one of the places testing that boundary. The Fourth Circuit’s ruling sits in a longer fight over whether event contracts on a CFTC-regulated venue should be treated under federal commodities law or under state sports-wagering rules. That question matters because it shapes which regulator gets the final say when prediction markets resemble betting markets.
For Kalshi and its users, the immediate practical result is that Maryland’s sports-wagering framework remains available to state authorities against those contracts while the injunction issue is unsettled. That leaves the platform facing a legal environment in which the same product can be treated differently depending on how a court reads federal preemption. Builders working on event contracts now have to design with the possibility that state gaming rules will still apply even when the product trades on a federally supervised market.
This case sits in the wider tension between a national market structure and state control over gambling. If federal commodities law does not clearly displace state sports-betting rules, prediction markets may not get the uniform treatment that crypto and derivatives firms often seek when they build across state lines. At the same time, allowing states to enforce their own rules keeps local gambling policy in play instead of letting a CFTC listing settle the issue on its own.
Still open is whether Kalshi will keep pressing the injunction fight and whether other courts will read the Commodity Exchange Act the same way. The Nov. 18 opinion resolves only the request to block Maryland’s rules for now, not the full underlying dispute over how sports event contracts fit into federal and state law. A later merits ruling, or a different circuit, would be needed to settle the broader question with more finality.
Market reaction i
The total crypto market rose 1.4% in the 4 hours after the first headline, after falling 0.9% in the 2 hours before.
47 prices, one every 30 minutes
Coverage timeline
Every piece in order, with the time its news medium declares — if it is not believable we use ours and say so — and what it added to what was already known at that point. Arriving first is not the same as adding something.